1. Differences Between Consumption Tax and Value-Added Tax (VAT)

Consumption Tax and Value-Added Tax (VAT) are indirect taxes imposed on consumption and adopted by many countries, but their mechanisms and operations differ significantly.

Japan introduced its Consumption Tax in 1989, currently applying a standard tax rate of 10%, with a reduced rate of 8% for certain food items and other essentials.

In contrast, the Value-Added Tax widely used in European countries features multiple tax rates that vary across member states. While VAT is levied on business transactions, it is ultimately borne by the final consumer through tax credits at each stage.

Another key feature of Japan's Consumption Tax is the tax exemption system for export transactions, ensuring that goods and services produced in Japan but consumed overseas are not taxed.

In countries with VAT, export tax exemption procedures tend to be more complex, increasing the administrative burden on businesses.

For example, in EU countries, companies must maintain proper records of export documents and purchases to qualify for export tax exemption. This requirement increases management complexity, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises.

On the other hand, Japan's relatively simple tax exemption process benefits companies that actively engage in exports.
 

2. Mechanism of Sales Tax in the United States

The United States applies Sales Tax as its consumption tax, but its structure differs significantly from those in Japan and Europe.

Sales Tax is determined at the state and local levels, resulting in varying tax rates and taxable items across different jurisdictions. For example, California has a general tax rate of approximately 7.25%, while Texas applies a 6.25% rate. Some states, such as Oregon and Delaware, do not impose Sales Tax at all.

Additionally, Sales Tax is typically levied only at the point of final consumer purchase and does not apply to business-to-business transactions.

While this system may seem straightforward, interstate transactions and online sales create significant challenges. Following the 2018 Wayfair ruling, many states began requiring online sellers to collect Sales Tax on out-of-state sales.

Consequently, foreign companies entering the U.S. market must navigate varying state regulations, adding to their tax compliance burden.
 

3. Choosing and Managing Tax-Exempt Business Status

Under Japan’s Consumption Tax system, businesses with taxable sales of 10 million yen or less in the base period (usually two years prior) qualify as Tax-Exempt Businesses, meaning they are not required to pay Consumption Tax.

While this status reduces administrative burdens for small businesses, it comes with the drawback of being unable to issue qualified invoices to taxable businesses.

The introduction of Japan’s invoice system in 2023 has made the decision to remain a Tax-Exempt Business more complex. Without a qualified invoice, business partners cannot claim input tax deductions, potentially discouraging transactions with tax-exempt entities.

Retaining tax-exempt status simplifies administrative processes but may limit business opportunities. Conversely, registering as a taxable business increases tax compliance responsibilities but ensures smoother business relationships. Companies should carefully assess their business scale and transaction structure when making this decision.
 

4. Background and Impact of the Invoice System

Japan introduced the invoice system (qualified invoice storage method) to enhance transparency and fairness in its Consumption Tax system. Under this system, only registered businesses can issue qualified invoices, which recipients must retain to claim input tax deductions.

This new requirement adds complexity to tax management, particularly for foreign companies. Businesses must properly manage invoices and verify their suppliers’ tax status, requiring more detailed tax processing.

However, the invoice system also offers long-term benefits, such as reducing the risk of tax audits and enhancing credibility with business partners by clarifying tax obligations.
 

5. Tax Considerations in Cross-Border Transactions

For foreign companies operating in Japan, managing Consumption Tax in cross-border transactions is crucial. While export transactions are tax-exempt, businesses must maintain accurate records and supporting documents to qualify. Conversely, import transactions are subject to Consumption Tax, requiring proper declaration and deduction procedures.

In Europe’s VAT system, cross-border transactions within the EU involve additional complexities due to varying national tax rates and regulations. Businesses must apply appropriate tax rates and comply with different reverse charge rules.

Although Japan’s Consumption Tax system is relatively straightforward, staying updated with regulatory changes and maintaining compliance is essential.

Foreign companies handling import and export transactions in Japan should work with tax professionals to mitigate tax risks. Best practices include ensuring accurate customs clearance procedures and properly calculating taxable import values.
 

6. International Comparison of Consumption Tax Systems

Comparing Japan’s Consumption Tax, Europe’s VAT, and the U.S. Sales Tax reveals that Japan’s system is relatively simple.

Japan’s single tax rate, export tax exemption, and clear business classification rules provide advantages for foreign companies entering the Japanese market.

However, recent changes, such as the invoice system and tax-exempt business policies, have added complexity. By contrast, Europe’s VAT involves multiple tax rates and country-specific adjustments, increasing administrative costs for cross-border transactions. In the U.S., differing state-level Sales Tax regulations create compliance challenges for businesses.
 

7. Practical Tax Processing Considerations in Japan

Foreign companies operating in Japan should take note of the following tax processing considerations:

• Invoice system compliance: Register as a qualified invoice issuer and ensure proper invoice issuance and storage.
• Transaction management with tax-exempt businesses: Identify business partners’ tax classifications and assess the impact on input tax deductions.
• Accurate handling of import and export transactions: Maintain proper documentation for export tax exemption and correctly declare import Consumption Tax.
• Monitoring tax law updates: Stay informed about legal changes and consult tax professionals for compliance.

Leveraging tax software and expert consultants can help streamline tax management in Japan. Foreign companies, in particular, should seek support from professionals familiar with Japan’s tax system and international tax regulations.
 

8. 2024 Revisions to the Business Tax Exemption System

The 2024 revisions to Japan’s Consumption Tax law introduced significant changes affecting foreign businesses:

• Revised tax exemption rules based on taxable sales: Businesses with taxable sales exceeding 10 million yen during the specified period are no longer tax-exempt, regardless of salary payments.
• Changes to tax exemption for newly established foreign corporations: Companies with capital of 10 million yen or more are now required to pay tax upon starting domestic operations.
• New criteria for tax payment obligations: Companies with taxable sales exceeding 500 million yen or total revenue (including overseas sales) exceeding 5 billion yen must pay Consumption Tax.
• Exclusion of simplified tax system for businesses without a permanent establishment (PE): Non-resident businesses without a PE in Japan can no longer apply simplified tax rules or the 20% special provision.

Frequent changes to Japan’s tax law require businesses to stay informed and adjust accordingly.
 

9. Summary

Japan’s Consumption Tax system is known for its simplicity and transparency, offering advantages to foreign businesses. However, the introduction of the invoice system and revised tax-exempt business rules have added new complexities.

Compared to Europe’s VAT and the U.S. Sales Tax, Japan’s system is relatively intuitive but requires compliance with unique rules and regulations. Foreign companies entering Japan must fully understand the system and implement appropriate tax strategies.

For successful tax management in Japan, businesses should not only compare international tax systems but also develop practical, detail-oriented compliance strategies. Seeking expert guidance and maintaining efficient tax operations can contribute to business success in Japan.

Contact us

Complete this form and an RSM Shiodome Partners representative will be in touch.